Deputy vs When I Work for a business with 3 locations
At 3 locations and 30 staff, When I Work is cheaper: its multiple-locations plan is 30 × $5 = $150/month, while Deputy Core is 30 × $7.25 = $217.50/month. Deputy costs $67.50/month more on monthly billing ($45 more on annual Core at 30 × $6.50 = $195). What it adds: a Paycor payroll add-on on annual Core and Pro plans in the US, biometric time clocking on Core, and a published SMS rate of 1¢ per 160 characters.
Cost at 3 locations and 30 staff
Example, monthly billing: When I Work multiple locations = 30 users × $5 = $150/month. Deputy Core = 30 × $7.25 = $217.50/month. Difference: $217.50 − $150 = $67.50/month.
Managers: Deputy's pricing FAQ says all users, administrators and supervisors count, so 30 staff plus 3 managers is 33 × $7.25 = $239.25. When I Work does not state a billing rule; if 3 managers count, 33 × $5 = $165. Annual billing: Deputy Core is $6.50 per user (30 × $6.50 = $195); When I Work shows no separate annual price.
The cheaper plans have limits. Deputy Lite is 30 × $5.50 = $165/month, but Deputy's help center says Lite can select only 1 location at a time in the Scheduling tab. When I Work's $2.50 plan is for a "Single location or schedule". On November 12, 2026 When I Work's pricing page also served a second version that lists multi-location scheduling under a $2.50 Essentials plan (30 × $2.50 = $75), so check the version you see.
Side by side
| Item | Deputy | When I Work |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Per user per month; managers and admins count; $30/month minimum on monthly plans | Per user per month: $2.50 single location, $5 multiple locations |
| Cost, 3 locations / 30 staff | Core: 30 × $7.25 = $217.50/month (monthly billing); 30 × $6.50 = $195 on annual billing | Multiple locations: 30 × $5 = $150/month (no separate annual price shown) |
| Free plan | Not found on Deputy's site (free trial only) | Not found on When I Work's site (14-day trial only) |
| Scheduling | Basic on Lite; advanced scheduling and auto-scheduling on Core | Yes, with auto scheduling |
| Time clock | Basic on Lite; biometrics time clocking on Core | Built-in time clock in both plans (two-plan version of the page) |
| Swaps / open shifts | Shift swap and find replacement from Lite; open shift types listed in the help center | Shift swapping and open shift planning in every plan |
| Time off | Leave and availability management | Time off and availability management |
| Payroll | Deputy Payroll enabled by Paycor: $8/user/month + $49 base, on annual Core and Pro in the US | Payroll integrations; native payroll not found |
| POS | Square sales data into a sales vs wage graph | "Payroll and POS integrations"; which POS systems not checked |
| GPS | Geofencing (checked on Lite in Deputy's compare table) | Clock in using GPS or geofencing |
| SMS | 1¢ USD per 160 characters in the US, sent messages only | Schedule updates by SMS using reply keywords; cost not found |
| Trial | Free trial; length not found | 14 days, no credit card |
Choose When I Work if…
- Price per user decides it: at 30 users it is $67.50/month less than Deputy Core, and $74.25 less at 33 users if managers count at both ($239.25 − $165).
- You want the multi-location plan at $5 per user rather than $7.25.
- You want a trial with no credit card: When I Work states 14 days, no card required.
Choose Deputy if…
- You want payroll from the same vendor. Example: 30 × $8 + $49 = $289/month for Deputy Payroll, on top of annual Core at $195/month.
- You want biometric time clocking, which Deputy lists on Core.
- You send schedules by text and want a published rate: 1¢ per 160 characters in the US.
Where Assistlify fits
Assistlify is an early-access app with weekly schedules, staff assigned to one or more locations, clock in/out with breaks, time-off requests, and cash-drawer and stock counts per location, at one flat price per business, billed every 28 days rather than per user. Drawer and stock counts were not found on Deputy's or When I Work's sites. It does not list shift swaps, payroll, POS integrations, GPS or SMS, all of which Deputy and When I Work list. Its price is not published, so we cannot say whether it costs less. You can try it in the preview workspace.
Related: cost of 10 scheduling apps at 3 stores and 30 staff, Deputy alternative for 2-5 locations, When I Work alternative for 2-5 locations.
Questions
Is When I Work cheaper than Deputy?
Yes at 3 locations and 30 staff: 30 × $5 = $150/month vs Deputy Core at 30 × $7.25 = $217.50/month, both on monthly billing.
Do managers count as users in Deputy?
Yes. Deputy's pricing FAQ says all users, administrators and supervisors count, so 30 staff and 3 managers on Core is 33 × $7.25 = $239.25/month.
Does Deputy or When I Work have a free plan?
Neither lists one: Deputy's pricing page offers a free trial, and When I Work shows a 14-day trial with no credit card required.
Sources
- Deputy pricing (checked 2026-11-12)
- Deputy help: pricing plans (checked 2026-11-12)
- Deputy help: downgrading your plan (checked 2026-11-12)
- Deputy Square integration (checked 2026-11-12)
- When I Work pricing (checked 2026-11-12)
- When I Work help: receiving your schedule by SMS (checked 2026-11-12)