Can you deduct register shortages from an employee's pay?
Under the federal FLSA you may deduct a register shortage only if it does not cut an employee's pay below the $7.25 federal minimum wage or into required overtime, and the US Department of Labor's Fact Sheet #16 (revised July 2009) names a minimum wage cashier made to repay a drawer shortage as an illegal practice. For a tipped employee paid a cash wage below $7.25 under a tip credit, DOL Fact Sheet #15 says any register-shortage deduction is illegal. State law can be stricter: New York's Department of Labor lists cash shortages as an illegal deduction, and Washington's L&I bars register-shortage deductions during ongoing employment.
The federal rule (FLSA)
The US Department of Labor's Fact Sheet #16, "Deductions From Wages for Uniforms and Other Facilities Under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)" (revised July 2009), sets four limits that apply to cash drawer shortages:
- Costs that are for the employer's benefit, including theft of the employer's property by the employee or others, may not reduce an employee's earnings below the required minimum wage ($7.25 an hour, effective July 24, 2009) or overtime compensation.
- This holds "even if an economic loss suffered by the employer is due to the employee's negligence."
- An employer may not avoid the rule by having the employee repay the employer in cash instead of through a deduction.
- The fact sheet's first "typical problem" is "a minimum wage employee working as a cashier is illegally required to reimburse the employer for a cash drawer shortage."
- For a tipped employee paid a cash wage below $7.25 under a tip credit, DOL Fact Sheet #15 says any deduction for a cash register shortage is illegal, because it would reduce the employee's wages below the minimum wage.
How much the FLSA leaves room for
Fact Sheet #16's own uniform example: an employee paid $7.75 an hour for 30 hours can have at most $0.50 × 30 = $15.00 deducted that workweek. The fact sheet applies the same restriction to other employer-benefit items.
Example: a cashier earns $8.00 an hour and works 35 hours. The room above the federal minimum is (8.00 − 7.25) × 35 = $26.25 for that workweek. A $40.00 shortage leaves 40.00 − 26.25 = $13.75 that could not be taken that week under the federal floor, and a cashier paid $7.25 has $0.00 of room. This arithmetic covers federal law only; a higher state minimum wage or a state ban on shortage deductions changes it.
States whose labor agency addresses register shortages
Each row is from the state agency page listed in the sources; rules not stated there are not added here.
| State | What the state agency says | Page date |
|---|---|---|
| California | The DLSE says an employer cannot deduct a cash shortage caused by mistake or accident, and that an IWC Wage Order exception allows it only if the employer shows a dishonest or willful act or gross negligence, an exception the DLSE cautions may not comply with the Labor Code. | No date shown |
| Missouri | The Division of Labor Standards says an employer may deduct for cash register shortages as long as the deductions do not take the employee's wages below the required minimum hourly wage rate. | No date shown |
| New York | The NYS Department of Labor lists cash shortages among the illegal deductions from wages. | No date shown |
| North Carolina | NCDOL says a current employee's wages may be reduced for cash shortages only with written authorization, seven days' notice and without cutting into minimum wage or time-and-one-half overtime, and the seven-day notice does not apply once employment ends. | Revised October 2017 |
| Washington | L&I says register shortages may not be deducted during ongoing employment even when the employee had sole access and counted the till at the start and end of the shift, and allows a final-paycheck deduction only under an oral or written agreement, established cash-acceptance policies, sole access, start-and-end counts and a shortage in the final pay period, without going below minimum wage. | No date shown |
We did not check other states' agency pages for this article. A state missing from the table is not a state where deductions are allowed; check its labor department, or start from its page under labor laws by state.
What employers can do instead
California's DLSE says that for cash drawer shortages an employer may take disciplinary action up to and including termination, and may sue in court to recover losses. The other agency pages above do not address alternatives. Steps that reduce shortages without touching pay:
- One cashier per drawer per shift, so each short has one name (Washington's final-paycheck rule also depends on sole access).
- A count at the start and end of every shift, signed by the cashier; how is in how to count a cash drawer.
- Blind counts, so the counter cannot make the total match.
- A written cash policy the cashier signs at hire; the template is in cash handling policy for employees.
- A per-cashier over/short log reviewed weekly (cash drawer over/short).
If you run stores in more than one state, check each state separately: Missouri's agency page allows shortage deductions that stay above the minimum hourly wage, while New York's lists cash shortages as an illegal deduction.
This is general information, not legal advice. Check your state labor department for current rules.
This is general information, not legal advice. Check your state labor department for current rules.
Questions
Can an employer make a cashier pay for a shortage?
Under the FLSA, not if it takes pay below the $7.25 federal minimum wage or into overtime; DOL Fact Sheet #16 calls requiring a minimum wage cashier to repay a drawer shortage illegal, Fact Sheet #15 says any shortage deduction is illegal for a tipped employee paid a cash wage below $7.25 under a tip credit, and some states, such as New York, ban shortage deductions.
Can the employee pay the shortage back in cash instead?
DOL Fact Sheet #16 says employers may not avoid the minimum wage and overtime limits by having the employee reimburse them in cash instead of a deduction.
Can you deduct a cash shortage from pay in California?
California's DLSE says no when the shortage comes from mistake or accident; an IWC Wage Order exception requires the employer to show a dishonest or willful act or gross negligence, and the DLSE cautions it may not comply with the Labor Code.
Can you take a till shortage from a final paycheck in Washington?
Washington L&I allows it only with an oral or written agreement, established cash policies, sole access to the till, start-and-end counts and a shortage in the final pay period, and not below minimum wage.
Sources
- US DOL WHD Fact Sheet #16: Deductions From Wages for Uniforms and Other Facilities Under the FLSA (revised July 2009) (checked 2026-11-12)
- US DOL WHD Fact Sheet #15: Tipped Employees Under the FLSA (no date shown) (checked 2026-11-12)
- California DIR, Labor Commissioner's Office (DLSE): Deductions FAQ (checked 2026-11-12)
- Missouri Department of Labor, Division of Labor Standards: Reducing employee wages (checked 2026-11-12)
- New York State Department of Labor: Illegal Deductions (checked 2026-11-12)
- North Carolina Department of Labor: Deductions from Wages (revised October 2017) (checked 2026-11-12)
- Washington State Department of Labor & Industries: Paycheck Deductions (checked 2026-11-12)